It begins at about 42:00 in the broadcast:
http://media18.podbean.com/pb/88611952fce12445fb58...
Does anyone know anything more about this?
TruthMove Forum » TruthMove Main Forum
Chossudovsky accuses Nafeez Ahmed of plagiarism (6 posts)
-
Posted 12 years ago #
-
Sorry I didn't listen to the podcast, but Ahmed writes about Peak Oil in his writings and Chossudovky's website has published Peak Oil Denial articles.
Posted 12 years ago # -
The link isn't working anymore...
Posted 12 years ago # -
Try this:
http://lifeboathour.podbean.com/mf/web/sh59nm/Life...
I have always noticed the large amount of junk on Chossudovsky's website. On the other hand, I think that he would be a pretty good candidate to impersonate Werner Herzog.
Also, at 35:00, a caller asks Chossudovsky about Peak Oil.
Posted 12 years ago # -
Can you give us the gist?
What does he say Nafeez took? I know that Nafeez's work is very carefully sourced. In the 9/11 works, in his use of secondary material he constantly provides citations and mentions authors and sources on a page by page basis. He makes no claims to journalism and does little archival research (more than, ahem, Michel) and makes it clear throughout that his work is synthetic.
I respect Michel's work, but he has a tendency to fly off the ego-handle that I have also witnessed in person.
Posted 12 years ago # -
Ruppert goes through who he thought the original top people were in 9/11 research were and one of the individuals he names Nafeez Ahmed. Chossudovsky then says that Nafeez plagiarized both Ruppert's and Chossudovsky's work. He then says that Nafeez admitted in a letter that he plagiarized Chossudovsky's work. It is completely unspecific and it is quick because Ruppert changes the topic and says that Chossudovsky said the accusation distancing himself from it.
I know that Nafeez's work is very carefully sourced. In the 9/11 works, in his use of secondary material he constantly provides citations and mentions authors and sources on a page by page basis. He makes no claims to journalism and does little archival research (more than, ahem, Michel) and makes it clear throughout that his work is synthetic.
This I completely agree with.
Posted 12 years ago #
Reply
You must log in to post.